Two thick envelopes arrived by mail in mid-November. Our Medicare Advantage plan, the one we’ve had since 2009, was discontinued.
“It’s not personal, Sonny. It’s strictly business,” I mumbled to myself, remembering the famous line from “The Godfather.”
But it felt personal.
So there we were, among the nearly 3 million Medicare Advantage enrollees losing our medical insurance plan. Our plan was dropped by Humana, the insurance firm dropping the most people. United Healthcare and CVS Health also dropped a lot of enrollees.
It wasn’t a big surprise.
Our plan was a PPFS. That stands for preferred provider fee for service. They’re rare. Most plans are HMOs, health maintenance organizations. They assign you to a gate-keeper doctor who, in turn, must deal with a claim-denying insurance company. We never experienced any limitations in our PPFS plan. We were delighted with the doctors we had seen for over a decade.
That’s why I had thought it was only a matter of time before our plan was eliminated.
Then it was.
The Dread of Choosing.
What I dreaded was researching plans and figuring out what to do next. It’s complicated. And you can’t help thinking you’re about to make a huge mistake.
Let me guide you through just two of the choice needles we threaded. Medicare clients divide into two very different camps. The biggest camp is people who are income strained. They need a plan that will help them avoid most health care costs. Until recently, Advantage plans appeared to meet that need. Premiums were low to nonexistent; co-pays were small, side benefits were good and the maximum out-of-pocket wasn’t frightening.
Another group is people with sufficient income to pay normal medical bills. Still, they need insurance against huge bills. Medigap insurance plans are tailored to meet this need. The biggest problem with Medicare only is that it has no limit to how much your care can cost. While it will cover most things most of the time, it can bankrupt you if you have a serious illness, need repeated treatments or are hospitalized for any length of time.
The Medicare CoPay Trip Wire.
Why is that? Simple. Original Medicare has 20 percent co-pays. They can add up fast. One hospitalization can ruin the rest of your life.
There was a time when the purchase of a Medicare Advantage Plan (Medicare part C) would reduce, or eliminate, out-of-pocket expenses. It would also set a low out-of-pocket limit. But those times are over. Premiums are rising. So are the out-of-pocket limits. On Medicare.gov, for instance, I found out-of-pocket limits of $3,900, $9,850 and $5,350 for WellCare Simple (HMO), Wellpoint Medicare Advantage 2 (HMO-POS) and Humana Gold Plus H0028-037 (HMO), respectively.
Comparing Spending Limits.
That’s higher than the $2,950 out-of-pocket limit for the high-deductible plan F Medigap policies that have relatively low monthly premiums. Here’s how the plan we lost compares with the replacement choice we made:
- Under the closed Humana Advantage Plan, we paid $29 a month each in premiums, $58 total. We faced a maximum out-of-pocket cost of $6,750 each, or $13,500 total.
- Under our new Medigap Plan, a high-deductible Plan F, we’ll be paying different monthly premiums of $155 and $130 with a 10 percent discount for being a couple. So we’ll pay $256.50 a month in premiums. And we’ll face a maximum out-of-pocket cost of $2,950 each, or $5,900 total.
Basically, we’ll be paying $200 a month, or $2,400 a year, more in premiums. In exchange, we’re cutting our out-of-pocket exposure by $3,800 each or $7,600 total. That seems like a reasonable trade to both of us. The additional premium gives us complete freedom for choosing our doctors and places of treatment. And we’ve got a reasonable limit on our out-of-pocket expenses.
The Good Side of Being Dropped.
We couldn’t do this if our Advantage plan had not been dropped. Unless you’ve been dropped, you must medically qualify to change plans. And while we’re both very healthy, we both have pre-existing conditions that would have made our premium payments higher.
From our perspective, the cancellation of our Advantage plan was a fortuitous event. It can work that way for many others, too.
But What About Part D?
Medicare Advantage plans usually include Medicare Part D, the coverage for prescription drugs. Medigap plans don’t. This means switching from an Advantage plan to a Medigap plan also means you need to buy a Part D policy. Here, like everything else in medical care, we face an abundance of choices and premiums.
In our rural area, I found premiums that varied from $33.20 a month to $199 a month. We chose the least expensive plan because we are relatively healthy, have few prescriptions and all are generic. It may not always be this way, but our decision will help us keep our expenses as low as possible for as long as possible.
There’s another reason to avoid higher premium Part D plans if your current prescriptions are generic. When I plugged in the three prescriptions that I take (my wife takes only one), I found significant differences in what they cost at three different local pharmacies. Total annual costs were $338.38, $382.90 and $519.14 for a year.
The Alternate Route to Filling Prescriptions.
But I could fill all three prescriptions for less than any of the three pharmacies by signing up for Mark Cuban’s CostPlusDrugs!
Placing prescriptions directly with CostPlusDrugs filled my prescriptions for $112. For a year. That’s a fraction of the cost buying through an insurance policy and local pharmacies.
A visit to the GoodRX website brought similar good news. Including the $120 annual membership cost, my total for the year would be $160.
So let me be a bit hard-nosed here. If we must pay two or three times as much for generic drugs AND pay an insurance premium, is that really insurance?
The Part D Revenue Sharing Cabal.
In fact, Medicare Part D insurance policies are a type of political/corporate organization. I call them RMOs. That’s short for revenue maintenance organizations, cabals of major pharmaceutical companies, pharmacies, and the insurance industry that gets a cut of every money stream.
The RMOs are assembled by our elected representatives in Washington. They put the deals together and just happen to receive generous campaign funding from all three sources. This has got to stop.
I’m thinking we’ll pay the required insurance premiums. But we’ll fill our prescriptions from CostPlusDrugs. It’s another way to vote for true free enterprise. And real change.
Thank you, Mark Cuban.
Related columns:
Scott Burns, “Why You Should Run For Congress Now!”, 7/25/2026: https://scottburns.com/why-you-should-run-for-congress-now/
Sources and References:
Movieclips.com: “It’s not personal, Sonny. It’s strictly business”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0qvpcfYFHcw
Home page of CostPlusDrugs: https://www.costplusdrugs.com
Home page of GoodRX: https://www.goodrx.com
Home page of Medicare.gov: https://www.medicare.gov
This information is distributed for education purposes, and it is not to be construed as an offer, solicitation, recommendation, or endorsement of any particular security, product, or service.
Photo: Scott Burns, This isn’t the healthcare casino. It’s a casino in Henerson, NV where the recent annual Bogleheads meeting was held.
(c) Scott Burns, 2026